Michael Phillips and A.O. Scott review "The Other Guys", "Step Up 3D", "Lebanon", "The Disappearance of Alice Creed", and "Middle Men". In the 'Over/Under' segment, the critics choose their picks for the most overrated and underrated dance films of the past few years. A.O. Scott picked "Chicago" as his choice for the most overrated film, and "The Company" as his most underrated. Michael Phillips chose "Moulin Rouge" as his pick for the most overrated, and "Pennies From Heaven" for the most underrated.