Michael Phillips and A.O. Scott review "Knight and Day", "The Killer Inside Me", "South of the Border", "Restrepo", "I Am Love" and "Wild Grass". In the 'Over/Under' segment, the critics choose their picks for the most overrated and underrated films Starring Tom Cruise. A.O. Scott picked "Rain Man" as his choice for the most overrated film, and "Magnolia" as his most underrated. Michael Phillips chose "Top Gun" as his pick for the most overrated, and "Collateral" for the most underrated.