Michael Phillips and A.O. Scott review "Robin Hood", "Letters to Juliet", "Just Wright", and "Daddy Longlegs". In the 'Over/Under' segment, the critics choose their picks for the most overrated and underrated films by Ridley Scott. A.O. Scott picked "Gladiator" as his choice for Ridley Scott's most overrated film, and "Matchstick Men" as his most underrated. Michael Phillips chose "Thelma and Louise" as his pick for the most overrated, and 1979's "The Duellists" for the most underrated.